Freedom in Naʾini’s Political Thought: A Contemplation on the Practical and Ideological Grounds

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Faculty of Political Science, Islamic Sciences and Culture Academy, Qom, Iran

2 PhD Student, Political Thought, Imam Khomeini Research Center

Abstract

The Shiite political thought experienced new evolutions with the entrance of new concepts and thoughts in the Constitutionalism period. One of those evolutions was the scholars’ effort to explain and describe the conditions and foundations of legitimacy of the right to ‘freedom’ which had little record in the Shiite political thought up to that era. Mirza Muhammad Hussein Naʾini, one of the constitutionalist scholars of that day, attempted to offer a new reading of that concept. Accordingly, the present study uses Skinner’s hermeneutic method to investigate Ayatollah Naʾini’s political thought regarding freedom and answer the following question: “In which practical and ideological ground was Naʾini’s view on freedom formed?” The findings of the study show that the ideological grounds of that thought have been formed by the non-religious texts of the constitutionalist intellectuals on the one hand, and the religious texts of jurists opposing constitutionalism on the other hand. Similarly, its practical ground must be looked for inside the despotism of the Qajar rulers and constitutional revolution. Due to being placed inside such grounds, Naʾini negates despotism in Islam by proposing freedom and conceptual expansion of ḥurriyat (freedom), proving freedom as a divine right of the Muslims from the religious viewpoint. This conceptual reading prepares the round for getting away from inconsistency between freedom and Shariʿa in Naʾini’s political thought.

Keywords

References

  1. The Holy Quran

    ** Nahj al-Balagha

    1. Esfandiar, v. Keshishian Sirki, G., Hasanifar, A., Salar Kasraʾi, M. (1399 SH). “Barrasi Taṭbīqī Āzādī wa Qudrat Dowlat dar Andīshayi Siyāsī Ayatollah Nāʾini wa Sheikh Faḍlullāh Nūri” in Pazhūhishhāyi Tārīkhī Iran wa Isalām, no. 26, pp. 1-18.
    2. Abrahamian, Y. (1384 SH). Irān Beyn Du Inqilāb (Trans. Golmuhammadi, A. and Fattahi, I.). Tehran: Ney Publications.
    3. Adamiyyat, F. (1349 SH). Andīshahāyi Mīrzā Fatḥalī Ākhūndzāda. Tehran: Kharazmi.
    4. Adamiyyat, F. (1340 SH). Fikr Āzādī wa Muqaddamayi Nahḍat MashrūṭTehran: Sokhan.
    5. Adamiyyat, F. (n.d.). Īdiʾuluzhī Nahḍat MashrūṭTheran: Payam.
    6. Bashiriya, H. (1382 SH). Mawāniʿ Towsiʿayi Siyāsī dar Iran. Tehran: Gam Now.
    7. Turkaman, M. (1362 SH). Majmūʿaʾī az Rasāʾil wa Iʿlāmiyahā, Maktūbāt wa Rūznāmihāyi Sheikh Faḍlullāh Nūrī. Tehran: Rasa Institute.
    8. Tully, J. (1983). “Quentin Skinner’s Analysis of Politics”(Trans. Behruzi-lak, Gh.) in Periodical of Political Sciences, 7 (28), pp. 40-52.
    9. Soleymani, J. (1382 SH). “Ḥudūd wa Jāygāh Āzādī dar Andīshayi Siyāsī Mīrzā Nāʿīnī” in Āmūza Magazine, 3, pp. 241-274.
    10. Haʾeri, A. (1364 SH). Tashayyuʿ wa Mashrūṭiyat dar Iran wa Naqsh Iraniān Muqīm ʿIrāq. Tehran: Amirkabir Publications.
    11. Heydari Behnuya, A. (1389 SH). Andīshayi Siyāsī Ayatollah Mīrzā Muhammad Hussein Nāʾīnī. Qom: Bustan Ketab.
    12. Khan-Muhammadi, Y. (1392 SH). Tafsīr Siyāsī Qurān dar Iran MuʿāṣQom: Research Center of Islamic Sciences and Culture.
    13. Rajaʾi, F. (1373 SH). Maʿrikayi Jahānbīnīhā. Tehran: Ihya Ketab.
    14. Rafʿati-panah Mehrabadi, M. and Soleymani Dehkordi, K. (1395 SH). “Bāzkhānī Mafhūm Āzādī dar Maṭbūʿāt Mashrūṭa (1324-1327 AH). Muṭāliʿāt Farhangī”in Pazhūhishnāmayi Anjuman Irānī Tārīkh, 8 (30), pp. 97-126.
    15. Zareʿi, B. (1396 SH). Barrasī Muqāyisiʾī Andīshayi Siyāsī Nukhbigān Madhhabī Inqilāb Mashrūṭa wa Inqilāb Islāmī bā Taʾkīd bar Muṭahharī wa Nāʾīnī. Thesis. Qom: Mufid University.
    16. Zargari-nejad, Gh. (1374 SH). Rasāʾil Mashrūṭiyat: 18 Risāla wa Lāyiḥa darbārayi MashrūṭTehran: Kavir Publications.
    17. Talebov, A. (1324 SH). Masāʾil Ḥayāt. Tiflis: Gheyrat Publications.
    18. Tabatabaʾi, J. (1386 SH). Taʾammulī darbārayi Iran, Naẓariya Ḥukūmat Qānūn dar Iran. Tabriz: Sotouda.
    19. Firahi, D. (1392 SH). Fiqh wa Siyāsat dar Iran Muʿāṣir (vol. 1). Tehran: Ney Publications.
    20. Firahi, D. (1396 SH). Āstānayi Tajaddud “Sharḥ Tanbīh al-Umma wa Tanzīh al-Milla”. Tehran: Ney Publications.
    21. Firahi, D. (1395 SH). Āstānayi Tajaddud in Sharḥ Tanbīh al-Umma wa Tanzīh al-Milla”. Tehran: Ney Publications.
    22. Katouzian, M. (1379 SH). Iqtiṣād Siyāsī Iran (Trans. Nafisi, M. and ʿAzizi, K.). Tehran: Markaz Publications.
    23. Kavakebi, A. (1378 SH). Ṭabāyiʿ al-Istibdād yā Sirishthāyi Khudkāmigī (Trans. Qajar, A.). Qom: Bustan Ketab.
    24. Majlesi, M. (1403 AH). Biḥār al-Anwār (vol. 31, 2nd). Beirut: al-Wafaʾ Institute.
    25. Murtazavi, Kh. (1386 SH). “Tabyīn Rawish-shināsī Andīshayi Siyāsī az Manẓar Quentin Skinner” in Pazhūhishnāmayi ʿUlūm Siyāsī, 3 (1), pp. 159-191.
    26. Malekshahi-nejad, V. and Ahmadi, M. (1401 SH). “Barrasī Jāygāh Āzādī dar Andīshayi Siyāsī Aytollah Nāʾīnī” in Jāmiʿa-shināsī Siyāsī Iran Magazine, 5 (12), pp. 129-147.
    27. Naderi Zarna, S., Towhidfam, M., Bakhshayeshi Ardestani, A., Amini, A. (1400). “Jaygāh Āzādī dar Andīshayi Siyāsī Isaiah Berlin and Ayatollah Nāʾīnī” in Rahyāfthāyi Inqilāb Islāmī, 15 (56), pp. 339-356.
    28. Nazem al-Dowla, M. (1381 SH). Risālahāyi Mīrzā Malkam Khan: Risālayi Ṣirāṭ al-Mustaqīm. Tehran: Ney Publications.
    29. Naʾini, M. (n.d.). Tanbīh al-Umma wa Tanzīh al-Milla yā Ḥukūmat az Naẓar Islām. Tehran: Inteshar Corporation.
    30. Varaʿi, J. (1342 SH). Pazhūhishī dar Andīshayi Siyāsī Nāʾīnī. Qom: Secretariat of the Assembly of Leadership Experts.   

     

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics